Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

209 Bay Street
Shanty Bay Simcoe L0L 2L0

$4,999,900
Residential Freehold beds: 5 baths: 5.0

Main Photo: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 1: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 2: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 3: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 4: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 5: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 6: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 7: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 8: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 9: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 10: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 11: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 12: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 13: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 14: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 15: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 16: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 17: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 18: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 19: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 20: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 21: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 22: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 23: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 24: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 25: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 26: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 27: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 28: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 29: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 30: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 31: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 32: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 33: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 34: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 35: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 36: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 37: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 38: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 39: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Photo 40: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
S12386085
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
5
A rare opportunity to own a true waterfront retreat in the heart of Shanty Bay. Set on a quiet, dead-end street, this exceptional lakefront property offers almost 200 feet of south-facing shoreline with crystal-clear, deep waterperfect for swimming, boating, and soaking in panoramic views across Kempenfelt Bay. Set on a beautifully treed, private lot, this estate includes a main cottage, guest house, and a bunkie above the garagetotalling 12 bedrooms, 8 bathrooms, and 3 kitchens. Whether you're hosting extended family, entertaining guests, or exploring rental income, theres space for everyone. Enjoy unobstructed lake views from most principal rooms, and step outside to a host of outdoor features including: a Private concrete waterfront patio, a Marine railway with covered boat slip and an Expansive rooftop deck above the boat slipperfect for sunset entertaining. The main cottage exudes warmth and character, featuring wood floors, a charming stone fireplace, a Muskoka room with stunning views, and a cozy third-level loft. Additional highlights include: a Heated garage with bunkie above, Parking for 10+ vehicles, Secluded and a park-like setting with mature trees for total privacy. All this just 10 minutes to Barrie, Royal Victoria Hospital, shops, and servicesplus an easy 1-hour drive to Toronto. Enjoy quick boat access to Friday Harbours dining and amenities, and explore nearby Simcoe Loop Trail for walking and cycling. Whether you enjoy this special property as-is or explore its future severance or redevelopment potential, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a legacy lakefront estate in one of Lake Simcoes most desirable communities.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
2-Storey
Total Approx Floor Area:
3000-3500
Depth:
156'
Frontage:
200'
Lot Shape:
Irregular
Direction Faces:
South
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
5.0
Water supply:
Well
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
5
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
9
Heating type:
Forced Air
Heating Fuel:
Gas
Fireplaces:
2
Foundation:
Concrete Block
Roof:
Asphalt Shingle
Basement:
Full, Unfinished
Fireplace Features:
Living Room, Family Room, Wood, Natural Gas
Fireplace/Stove:
Yes
Alternative Power:
Generator-Wired
Garage:
Detached
Garage Spaces:
2.0
Other Structures:
Aux Residences
Parking Features:
Private Triple
Parking Spaces:
10
Total Parking Spaces:
12.0
Family Room:
Yes
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Taxes:
$14,417 / 2024
Assessment:
$- / -
Oro-Medonte
Shanty Bay
Simcoe
Waterfront, Wooded/Treed, Lake/Pond, Cul de Sac/Dead End
Generator - Partial, Auto Garage Door Remote
Deck, Patio, Year Round Living
Conservation Regulations
None
Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Oven/Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Appliances in bunkie and guest house. Docking. Generator.
None
Vinyl Siding
Breakwater, Trent System, Winterized, Boat Slip, Marine Rail
Direct
Clean, Rocky, Hard Bottom
None
South
Water, Lake
Direct, Unobstructive
Year Round Municipal Road
Lake Simcoe
Lake
UV System
Wet Slip, Bunkie
Private
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Living Room
21' × 15'
Hardwood Floor, Fireplace
Main
Dining Room
18' × 14'
Hardwood Floor, Overlook Water
Main
Kitchen
15' × 13'
Hardwood Floor
Main
Family Room
27' × 11'
Hardwood Floor
Second
Bedroom
16' × 14'
Hardwood Floor
Second
Bedroom
12' × 12'
Hardwood Floor
Second
Primary Bedroom
16' × 14'
Hardwood Floor
Second
Bedroom
13' × 11'
Hardwood Floor
Third
Bedroom
12' × 8'
Floor
Ensuite
Pieces
Other
Main
No
2
6' x 4' 2 Pc Bath
Second
Yes
5
10' x 8' 5 Pc Ensuite
Second
No
-
3'7" x 3'7"
Second
No
3
6'7" x 8'2" 3 Pc Bath
Second
No
3
6' x 6' 3 Pc Bath
Water Supply Types:
Drilled Well
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Septic
Air Conditioning:
Central Air
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Ensuite Laundry:
No
Laundry Level:
Main Level
Date Listed:
Sep 06, 2025
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 1 of 40
  • Photo 2: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 2 of 40
  • Photo 3: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 3 of 40
  • Photo 4: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 4 of 40
  • Photo 5: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 5 of 40
  • Photo 6: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 6 of 40
  • Photo 7: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 7 of 40
  • Photo 8: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 8 of 40
  • Photo 9: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 9 of 40
  • Photo 10: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 10 of 40
  • Photo 11: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 11 of 40
  • Photo 12: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 12 of 40
  • Photo 13: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 13 of 40
  • Photo 14: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 14 of 40
  • Photo 15: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 15 of 40
  • Photo 16: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 16 of 40
  • Photo 17: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 17 of 40
  • Photo 18: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 18 of 40
  • Photo 19: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 19 of 40
  • Photo 20: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 20 of 40
  • Photo 21: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 21 of 40
  • Photo 22: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 22 of 40
  • Photo 23: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 23 of 40
  • Photo 24: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 24 of 40
  • Photo 25: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 25 of 40
  • Photo 26: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 26 of 40
  • Photo 27: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 27 of 40
  • Photo 28: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 28 of 40
  • Photo 29: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 29 of 40
  • Photo 30: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 30 of 40
  • Photo 31: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 31 of 40
  • Photo 32: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 32 of 40
  • Photo 33: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 33 of 40
  • Photo 34: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 34 of 40
  • Photo 35: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 35 of 40
  • Photo 36: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 36 of 40
  • Photo 37: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 37 of 40
  • Photo 38: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 38 of 40
  • Photo 39: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 39 of 40
  • Photo 40: 209 Bay Street in Simcoe: Shanty Bay House for sale (Oro-Medonte)  : MLS®# S12386085
    Photo 40 of 40
Listed by RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY
Data was last updated September 9, 2025 at 01:15 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
11
Avg list price:
$1,775,000
Min list price:
$799,900
Max list price:
$37,000,000
Avg days on market:
45
Min days on market:
3
Max days on market:
791
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Shanty Bay. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
powered by myRealPage.com