Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

57 Penetang Street
Codrington Simcoe L4M 1V5

$729,900
Residential Freehold beds: 4 baths: 2.0

Main Photo: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 1: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 2: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 3: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 4: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 5: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 6: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 7: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 8: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 9: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 10: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 11: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 12: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 13: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 14: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 15: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 16: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 17: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 18: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 19: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 20: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 21: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 22: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 23: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 24: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 25: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 26: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 27: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 28: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 29: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 30: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 31: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 32: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 33: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 34: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Photo 35: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
S12343923
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
2
Versatile RM2-zoned duplex offering both immediate income and long-term growth potential. Located at 57 Penetang, this property is a rare opportunity for investors, multi-generational families, or those looking to live in one unit and rent the other. The large, deep yard invites you to explore the possibilities of a potential garden suite under Bill 23, adding another layer of future value and flexibility. The main unit features a spacious and bright two-bedroom apartment filled with natural light and a main floor living room that could be a 3rd bedroom. High ceilings and the charm of a century home combine beautifully with modern conveniences like in-unit laundry, making it an attractive space for tenants or an owner-occupier. The second unit offers two comfortable bedrooms, a large living room, an eat-in kitchen, and charming finishes throughout. This unit also includes in-unit laundry and the added benefit of basement access for extra storage or hobby space, further increasing its appeal. Both units are self-contained, providing privacy and functionality for occupants. With RM2 zoning in place, there is strong potential for future redevelopment or intensification, whether that means adding additional residential units, creating a garden suite, or exploring other high-density options permitted under the current zoning. This property's location offers convenient access to amenities, schools, parks, and transportation, making it an attractive choice for tenants and ensuring consistent rental demand. 57 Penetang is a rare combination of immediate cash flow, future development potential, and a flexible layout that works for a variety of living arrangements. Whether you're an investor seeking a solid addition to your portfolio or a buyer looking for a home with income to offset expenses, this property delivers on all fronts.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Duplex
Home Style:
2-Storey
Approx. Age:
100+
Total Approx Floor Area:
1500-2000
Depth:
184'
Frontage:
52'
Direction Faces:
South
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
2.0
Water supply:
Municipal
Kitchens:
2
Bedrooms Above Grade:
4
Kitchens Above Grade:
2
Rooms Above Grade:
10
Zoning:
RM2
Heating type:
Forced Air
Heating Fuel:
Gas
Foundation:
Stone
Roof:
Asphalt Shingle
Basement:
Partial Basement
Fireplace/Stove:
No
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Parking Features:
Private
Parking Spaces:
4
Total Parking Spaces:
4.0
Family Room:
No
Possession Details:
TBD
Pool:
None
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Not Subject to HST
Assessment Year:
2024
Taxes:
$5,157 / 2024
Assessment:
$- / 2024
Barrie
Codrington
Simcoe
Level, Library, School
None
Landscaped, Porch
None
Fridge X2, Stove X2, Washer and Dryer in Lower Unit, Washer/Dryer Combo in Upper Unit all as viewed prior to submitting offer and in As-Is condition
None
Wood, Vinyl Siding
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Kitchen
17' × 13'7"
Main
Living Room
17' × 14'6"
Main
Bedroom
10'10" × 9'11"
Main
Bedroom 2
12'⅞" × 10'2½"
Main
Living Room
15' × 11'8"
Second
Bedroom 4
10'2" × 8'
Second
Bedroom 5
14'1" × 9'10"
Second
Living Room
15' × 11'8½"
Second
Kitchen
12'11⅛" × 8'2"
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Sewer
Air Conditioning:
None
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Ensuite Laundry:
No
Date Listed:
Aug 14, 2025
Original Price:
$729,900
  • Photo 1: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 1 of 35
  • Photo 2: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 2 of 35
  • Photo 3: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 3 of 35
  • Photo 4: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 4 of 35
  • Photo 5: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 5 of 35
  • Photo 6: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 6 of 35
  • Photo 7: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 7 of 35
  • Photo 8: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 8 of 35
  • Photo 9: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 9 of 35
  • Photo 10: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 10 of 35
  • Photo 11: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 11 of 35
  • Photo 12: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 12 of 35
  • Photo 13: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 13 of 35
  • Photo 14: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 14 of 35
  • Photo 15: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 15 of 35
  • Photo 16: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 16 of 35
  • Photo 17: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 17 of 35
  • Photo 18: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 18 of 35
  • Photo 19: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 19 of 35
  • Photo 20: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 20 of 35
  • Photo 21: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 21 of 35
  • Photo 22: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 22 of 35
  • Photo 23: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 23 of 35
  • Photo 24: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 24 of 35
  • Photo 25: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 25 of 35
  • Photo 26: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 26 of 35
  • Photo 27: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 27 of 35
  • Photo 28: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 28 of 35
  • Photo 29: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 29 of 35
  • Photo 30: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 30 of 35
  • Photo 31: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 31 of 35
  • Photo 32: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 32 of 35
  • Photo 33: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 33 of 35
  • Photo 34: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 34 of 35
  • Photo 35: 57 Penetang Street in Simcoe: Codrington House for sale (Barrie)  : MLS®# S12343923
    Photo 35 of 35
Listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
Data was last updated August 27, 2025 at 08:15 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
22
Avg list price:
$729,900
Min list price:
$550,000
Max list price:
$1,249,000
Avg days on market:
53
Min days on market:
13
Max days on market:
477
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Barrie. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
powered by myRealPage.com