One of the most common and emotionally charged questions in Canadian real estate is: “Should I rent or buy a house?” The answer to rent vs own depends on many factors, including your financial goals (short and long-term), lifestyle, social group, market conditions, and even your stage in life. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a soon-to-retire homeowner wondering if it’s time to cash out and rent, the question of “Is it better to rent or Buy a house in Canada?” has never been more relevant.

So, let’s look at the financial and emotional dimensions of renting versus owning in Canada with comparisons, long-term considerations, and also some specific insights for retirees.

Do you want to stay informed about what’s happening in Simcoe County real estate? Get the latest news and early access to our listings by subscribing to our newsletter right here. 

Home Ownership vs Renting: The Basics

Home Ownership offers:

• You build equity over time as you pay down your mortgage and appreciation rises.
• You benefit from property appreciation- there are some swings, yes, but over time the real estate market has always had steady growth.
• You can fully renovate and personalize your space.
• You’re responsible for a wider variety of costs like- property taxes, maintenance, insurance and repairs.
• On the flip side, owning requires upfront costs- down payment, closing costs, and ongoing mortgage payments.

Since World War 2 and the promotion of homeownership by the government through various programs, including mortgage insurance and self-interest bank promotion, homeownership has become a symbol of success and financial stability. 

Renting offers:

• Lower upfront costs (no down payment, just first and last month’s rent).
• Predictable monthly expenses (rent + tenant insurance) with very small predictable rises in cost of rent managed by the Ontario Government once you are a tenant.
• No responsibility for property taxes or major repairs, even with appliances
• Flexibility to move with relatively short notice- 60 days in most cases
• No equity or asset growth

The traditional narrative that equates home ownership with success has changed somewhat- particularly in downtown core areas with younger, highly mobile people and also older retirees. 

Mortgage Vs Rent Over the Long Term

A key mistake people make when comparing mortgage vs rent is only looking at monthly payments. But that’s like comparing a gym membership to buying a home gym. One gives you short-term access, and the other builds long-term value.

Here’s an example:

Imagine you rent a home for $2,800/month. Contrast that with owning a similar home with a $3,300/month mortgage + $500 in taxes & maintenance. The difference is that you end up paying $1,000/month more to own a house. 

But consider where you will be after 25 years. 

• The renter spent $840,000 with no equity to show for it. 
• The owner paid more than $1 million – but now owns a $1.2M asset, mortgage-free.

Over time, homeownership shifts from expense to investment, while rent remains a cost with no return.

As the Globe and Mail and Financial Post have both noted in recent features on renting vs buying in Ontario, rising rents, inflation, and limited rental supply are increasingly tilting the long-term balance in favour of ownership for those who can afford it.

---

Understanding the local real estate market can help you decide whether to buy a home once and for all. The posts below are a great place to start:

• Barrie Luxury Real Estate Compared to Toronto
• How Does Real Estate Negotiation Work In Today’s Market? 
• Why Is It Critical to Buy and Sell a Home in the Same Market?

---

Is It Cheaper to Rent or Buy a House in Canada?

In the short term, yes- renting is often cheaper month to month. But in the long term, buying usually wins- because:

• You lock in housing costs (with a fixed mortgage).
• You benefit from rising home values (appreciation).
• You build equity- a form of forced savings.

The Bank of Canada estimates that real estate has historically appreciated at 4–5% annually across most Canadian markets.

Why Some Retirees Consider Renting:

• They want flexibility (to travel or move without the burden of a home).
• They want to unlock home equity for investment, lifestyle, or legacy planning with family.
• They want to simplify life- no snow shovelling, no roof repairs, no yard to maintain, no property tax headaches.

But There Are Trade-offs:

• Rents may increase significantly over time- controlled increases but generally between 1.5-2.5% per year.
• You lose the sense of control (landlord decisions, condo boards, lease terms).
• You forfeit long-term equity growth.

Ownership in Retirement Can Still Make Sense If:

• You want a stable home base.
• You can afford a condo or bungalow with low maintenance.
• You want to leave an asset to your children or estate.

Weeks Group Tip: Many retirees choose a hybrid model- selling the family home, buying something smaller or outside the city, and investing the leftover equity for income.

As personal finance expert Rob Carrick of The Globe and Mail has noted, “For financially secure retirees, renting is a lifestyle choice — not necessarily a savings plan.”

Bonus Wealth-Building Benefit: Equity Unlocks Opportunity

As you pay down your mortgage and your home value appreciates, you build home equity- the portion of the home you truly “own.”

This equity isn’t just theoretical. Homeowners in Canada can apply for a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC), which lets you borrow against that equity- often at lower interest rates than other types of loans.

Many informed and savvy Canadians use a HELOC to:

• Invest in additional property or stock opportunities.
• Start a small business for income and write-offs in retirement.
• Renovate and increase home value further.
• Consolidate higher-interest debt.

This access to low-cost borrowing power is one of the most overlooked net benefits of homeownership. It turns your house into a financial tool- not just a place to live.

Renting is like throwing money into a fireplace. Owning is like putting money into a furnace that heats your future- and even lets you draw on that heat to power other investments.

---

Barrie and Simcoe County are ideal choices, whether searching for a starter home or a luxury property. Learn more in the posts below:

• What to Look for in a Waterfront Home in Barrie
• What Does Barrie Real Estate Offer Home Buyers?
• Advantages of Owning a Luxury Home in Simcoe County

---

It’s a Personal Choice

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer for ‘Is it better to rent or buy a house in Canada’ but here’s a quick summary:

• If you want flexibility, lower upfront costs, or are unsure where you’ll be in a few years due to career hopping or lifestyle choices, Renting may be the right choice.
• If you want stability, long-term wealth, and a hedge against inflation- Buying makes more sense- especially in Canada’s appreciating real estate market.
• If you’re an affluent retiree, the question isn’t “can I afford to own?” but rather “does ownership still serve my lifestyle and estate goals?” If yes, downsizing may be the sweet spot.

We often have clients call us to meet with them just to have discussions around these topics. To get perspectives and examples of what we have experienced with so many clients over the years, you can call the Weeks Group, too!

If you’re ready to move up the property ladder, our Barrie real estate agents are happy to help. Reach out to us today at 705.305.4174 or email hello@weeksgroup.ca to take the first step.